Baker Boys: Inside the Surge (2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Outstanding film, very even-handed
bravejoker8 February 2011
Was privileged to be at the premier of this film at the National Infantry Museum and Soldier Center in Columbus, GA. I admit, I was apprehensive going into the film, which was shown on consecutive nights. I was concerned that it was going to be gory and be politically slanted one way or the other. I was pleasantly surprised on both fronts.

The film is in four episodes, and features a journalist who embedded with an element of the 3rd Infantry division during the Surge in Iraq. He joined the soldiers 90 days from the end of their deployment, as they were being redeployed on their Surge mission. Instead of getting his story and going home, the journo stayed with the soldiers for all 90 days, until they came home. He also checked in with them stateside.

The format is very open; the journo asked questions and let the soldiers answer. Parts were funny, parts were sad. All were thought-provoking.

In a Q&A after the film with the journalist and several of the soldiers in the film, the point was made (by both sides) that the Army didn't censor the film at all. Another point the journalist made: he is an ex-pat who has worked in Europe for many years. The news culture he comes from sends him out to film, and then the story is written from what the pictures show. This film is a product of that style. He says that in the U.S., we tend to write the story and get supporting pictures.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A must see for family members of soldiers with PTSD
kenneth-pierce19 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This film is 100% the real deal. I spent 14 months in support of OIF in 2003-04 as an infantryman. While there was perhaps a little more combat then this film portrays, the basic strategy was the same. Give them money, keep them happy, and hopefully they won't shoot at us anymore. Nothing could have been more frustrating to a group of soldiers.

This shouldn't discourage anyone from joining the military, but it should help future soldiers understand that war is not the glamorous Hollywood version you see on TV, and it never will be unless you're Special Forces. The reality shown in the film of families falling apart back home, while you're "defending freedom" is vividly portrayed, as well as the fact that so many soldiers do come home a mere shadow of their former selves. PTSD has claimed more lives from Suicide then actual combat.

The film receives -1 star from me because I don't think the reporters narcissistic comments were relevant at all to the film. If he would have kept the focus on the soldiers it would have been
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Interested in the Infantry? Not after this.
TheEmulator2310 September 2011
This was a terrific no holds barred look at the men in a particular company. There was truths from the men that are edited and removed from most other docs.

The thing that I did find sad is that it seemed like nothing is actually getting done. It's not the soldiers fault either. We are not engaged in combat like we were in WWII or even Vietnam for that matter. We're fighting a war it seems half-assedly. I applaud all the individuals including the reporters for giving us this info.

I would recommend every kid thinking about the military should watch and see that real life is not like "Modern Warfare." You don't get to re-spawn and try again.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed