Once Upon a Line (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Better than almost all the Oscar nominated animated shorts.
planktonrules19 February 2017
Despite very simple animation, this American short was my second favorite—better than all but Piper. Using simple lines and a mostly monochromatic color scheme, it wonderfully tells the story about a very dull and ordinary man who lives a very routine life…until he meets a woman, drawn in pink lines. What follows is a lot of upheaval in his life and the ending is bittersweet…but worth the wait.

I was most impressed by this film because it achieved so much while appearing so simple and stark. Much more improbably, it makes you care a lot about these very simple drawings…and shows that Alicja Jasina is an amazingly talented artist and director. Why this film was not nominated for the Oscar and four incredibly unpleasant and, at best, ordinary films were is beyond me....as it was the second best of the eight films shown at the Oscar Nomination special showing, but was listed as a 'commended film' only.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Another Polarizing Effort
Hitchcoc9 May 2019
This is a creatively presented short. It takes the most fundamental graphics possible, the use of black lines on a white background. These lines morph into the story of a man's life in a clever, creative way. I see that once again, instead of evaluating the film, they are ticked that it won a couple of amateur awards. Enough to give it a one star rating. This is an artistic effort and deserves some recognition, not treating it like "Zombies in the Bathhouse Prison."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It Could've Been a Contender
boblipton12 February 2017
I've just come from the movie theater, where I saw the nominees for the 2016 Best Animated Shorts Oscar. This was included, even though it was not nominated. It was my favorite of the eight and a fine cartoon on any terms.

This is a cartoon of a man who lives his routine, black-and-white life upon a black-and-white, horizontal line. Every day is like another. Then one day he runs into a feminine-looking, curvy, pink figure and matters change...and not just in the way I thought they would.

I love everything about this cartoon, from the story, to the manner in which it is drawn -- for a fan of silent comedy like me, the fact that the protagonist is represented by a pair of glasses and a straw boater hat, suggesting Harold Lloyd, is an asset -- to the jokes.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Robbed of Not Just an Oscar Nom, But the Win
emvan22 February 2017
This was on the 10-film Oscar shortlist and is one of three "Highly Commended" films that round out this year's theatrical program. In terms of innovative use of the medium, it's in a league of its own, and I thought it edged Disney's delightful PIPER, which doesn't push the envelope of animation an iota, as the best of the eight. I look for animated films to show us *something we've never seen before*, and ONCE UPON A LINE does that in a way that is transfixing and beautifully artful from start to end -- and yet is fundamentally simple. I suspect it didn't get the nomination because voters knew it was a student film. But that just makes it all the more remarkable.
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
This probably would have been the worst Oscar nominee that year
Horst_In_Translation7 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Once Upon a Line" is an 8-minute animated short film from 2016 that won a Student Academy Award and probably wasn't too far away from getting nominated at the 2017 Oscars either. Writer and director is Alicja Jasina. I do think that the animated short film category wasn't particularly strong this year and honestly, if a film like this almost managed to get in, it says a lot. A lot of my dislike here has to do with personal bias. The simple black-and-white style did almost nothing for me and the later inclusions of pink and green color turn out very forgettable as well. The pink parts had try-hard written all over them in the filmmaker's attempt to make the female character more memorable, but she ended up as forgettable and bland as the male protagonist. I can't deny that the animation style resulted in a smart moment here and there, but this was also far from enough, even for such a short film. And also in terms of the overall plot (leading a boring life, meeting a tempting woman on the way to work, fall in love, move in together and finally face the challenges of living under the same roof), there was nothing really well-done or memorable about this one here. The cat added almost nothing either and I have no clue what the meaning of the ending with the green color was? Did he now see more beauty in life thanks to the relationship, even if it did not work out? No idea. I cannot say I enjoyed this one and I hope Jasina steps things up with her next works, preferably with another animation style even.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I really enjoyed it!
Hellmant3 March 2017
'ONCE UPON A LINE': Four and a Half Stars (Out of Five)

An 8-minute animated short film, that was played with the 2017 Oscar nominated short films in theaters. This one was written and directed by Alicja Jasina. It's about a man who's daily routine life is suddenly changed, when he meets a woman he really likes. It's beautifully animated, and it also very cleverly tells a story that I think almost anyone can relate too. I love how upbeat it is, the music is very fitting and the visuals are colorful as well (in a very interesting and effective way). It's also romantic, and inspiring (oddly enough). I really enjoyed it.

Watch our movie review show 'MOVIE TALK' at: https://youtu.be/jPkZ6fs4g1c
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Not worth watching and a waste of time i want my money back
parhamghayour4 September 2017
I believe this is a very over rated animation. There is no flow of sentiment which is expected from an artist . There is no harmony between the animation and what the director of this animation calls music. The ending is out of the context. I personally did not observe any signs or feelings of love. I believe the reason is lack of life experience of director about meaning of true love that leaded to this disaster. Unfortunately Oscars is an overrated enterprise that pay attention only to rich spoiled kids from corrupted universities. It is beyond my understanding how this animation got nominated for anything. There are tons of other works that are far far better than this in any aspect but unfrotunately they don't come from universities that ask for 200000 dollar tuition.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Entertaining Short
Michael_Elliott26 February 2017
Once Upon a Line (2016)

*** (out of 4)

This here is a pretty entertaining animated short that shows how a man's routine life got a bit of energy after meeting a special woman. The animation to this is quite simple and I guess you'd say old-fashioned as well but that's just part of the charm and it turns out to be rather entertaining. This here was on a short list of films that just missed out on a Best Animated Short Oscar-nomination and I think it could be said that this here was worthy and especially compared to one of the film's that did get a nomination. I really liked the tone of the picture and I thought director Alicja Jasina did a very good job at telling the story and giving it a very good flow from start to finish.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed