"Supergirl" Reign (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Prophecies
ThomasDrufke4 December 2017
Putting aside last week's crossover episode of Supergirl, 'Reign' is 100% the best episode of Supergirl, and it's not even close. I've been critical of this show for many reasons, but one of the main ones being that it always feels very safe and lacks legitimate consequence. In large part, that's because the villains of each season have been lackluster to say the least. Well, that changed tonight as Reign officially made her debut and put more than just a stamp on National City.

This is the type of episode that happens when the show takes its time with its villain and doesn't force conflict. Odette Annable has already established herself as a worthy character on this show, but her arc into becoming the worldkiller Reign is truly taking shape nicely. Whether or not she even realizes what she is doing is yet to be determined but just from a pure physical standpoint, there hasn't been someone to even come close to matching Kara (at least as far as I can remember). The fight her and Kara had wasn't on the same level as Zod and Superman's in Man of Steel, but it certainly echoed it in a good way. Seeing Kara bleed is a powerful sight in and of itself.

I won't even pretend to know or understand Reign's full backstory yet, but I definitely like the idea of her presence being a prophecy and almost unavoidable. It certainly brings a different level of weight to this season, something which is greatly needed. This angle also gave us the return of Chad Rowe as Thomas Coville, who pleaded with Supergirl to take on 'the devil' known as worldkiller aka Reign. Coville's episode earlier this season was one of the best episodes of the entire series, so I welcome his return.

It's worth mentioning this episode followed in the long line of CW Arrowverse shows having a holiday themed mid-season finale, this time it seemed to bring James and Lena together romantically, something pretty much everyone expected. Other than that, the holidays only brought bad things upon National City, with Reign murdering people without any regard for human life. And although she made a great first impression, it's hard not to think of Peter Parker's emo Spider- Man moments in Spider-Man 3. Not in tone per-say, but just the fact that there is almost an unawareness to everything that is going on. The other vibe I got from the final moments was Arrow mid-season 3 finale when Ras pushed Oliver off the cliff. Anybody else feel that way?

9.0/10
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Finally, a Badass Villain!
lassegalsgaard-4528410 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
So, as I have expressed many times now, "Supergirl" is my least favorite of the four shows in the Arrowverse. One of the things that the show has always lacked is a great villain that really felt like a challenge to Kara. The first season started to set up a good villain with Astra, but she was killed off halfway through in favor of some evil male Kryptonian who I personally never got into. And then, the second season featured an ocean of different villains, before finally deciding to use Mon-El's evil mother. Again, a very lame and uninteresting villain. So far, this season has only really been able to offer some very lame episodes featuring Morgan Edge, who originally looked like the main villain to me. However, as the season has progressed, it has become very easy to see that Reign was always meant to be the main villain, and I am very happy that she has finally arrived, because she has done something that I didn't think was possible: creating an interesting, powerful and badass villain.

To be fair, this would have been a really good episode, even without Reign. She doesn't show up until very late, but there were many other things to enjoy. The first thing is that Mon-El is actually not a useless character this time around. They are doing something great with him and finally introducing the Legion of Superheroes, thereby giving him a real purpose in the show. I liked the opening scene that really explaining the Legion's situation and what happened to them, as well as getting some clarification of what actually happened to Mon-El when he was send into space.

The writing in this episode was not as bad as previous episodes. There were some great moments between the majority of the cast, especially at the Christmas party where the characters had some time to just focus on being happy and not focus on being superheroes or secret agents. I like those moments in these show, and unfortunately, we don't get that many of them. I will say, though, that some of the writing in the episode was really cringeworthy, and felt more like a regular "Supergirl" writing effort. There is some really bad dialogue, especially in the very first scene between Samantha and Ruby, where Samantha said something that felt like it was written for a sketch comedy or something like that.

I like the role that religion is playing in this season. It doesn't feel ham-fisted, and it actually feels different and exciting. They have never really touched on that element before in these shows, so the fact that they are doing it here is actually a blow of fresh air. They are also doing a much better job of making it seem relevant than something like "Legends of Tomorrow" is.

And then, we can talk about Reign, because she was an absolute badass in this episode. The big spotlight moment she got was her battle with Supergirl, in which she constantly had the upperhand and totally kicked her ass. This is something that I have missed in "Supergirl," because even though Supergirl has gotten her ass beaten in the past, it always felt very forced. It never felt like Supergirl was using all of her powers to try and fight off the villain. However, this time she was using everything she could to try and defeat Reign, and she did get a fair amount of blows in, but ultimately, she was the big loser of the fight, which I really appreciated. I hope that they continue this momentum with Reign, and doesn't end up her making her another mediocre big bad.

And Morgan Edge is still useless... The only purpose he serves in this show is some kind of threat to Lena, but they haven't used him to his full potential either. If the writers have nothing more to offer with this character, than just another second grade villain, then they should get rid of him quickly. He has been underused in this whole season, and it doesn't seem like they are going to do anything remotely intriguing with him.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This is the kind of episode the show needs
caravindan19945 December 2017
Romantic drama aside which were unnecessary, this episode was close to being perfect and this is what the writers need to do. Focus on the actual story or at least focus on something that is pointing towards the story.

As a fan of superheroes, I really hate to see filler scenes and of course filler episodes, though there were scenes that were not required in this episode, the rest of this episode was very engaging. And I really liked that they allowed the main character to take a beating. The fight was well shot.

Though there's no idea of what the story of rest of the season is going to be, this show will not lose its viewers if there are lot more episodes like this in future.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Kara Danvers investigates strange symbols appearing all over National City and faces her most powerful foe yet.
rwahab5 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This is hands down the best Supergirl episode yet. The entire episode and generally season 3 was building up to this episode and damn was it satisfying.

I've been a loyal fan since the start but I will admit the action sequences on the show tend to fall short save for a few exceptions. But this episode showed what a fight between gods really looks like and truly showcased Kara and mostly, Reign's power.

Seeing Kara bruised and battered like NEVER before while Reign not even having a scratch made me realize that this is the first villain on Supergirl who is (at the moment) more powerful than Kara and if wanted to, can easily destroy her.

I repeat, this is hands down, the best Supergirl episode yet.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This is the best yet in the show
ProducersGuide5 December 2017
This is the best hit yet in the show The length of the fight was acceptable

and finally...

Now she has an equal enemy

She deserves it for not accepting her new enemy's resistance on earth

Actually, that is the idea that a lot of fans waited for But, another thing is that this enemy should remain in the show till the final season's finale I mean if the creators are clever enough to do this

10/10
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Supergirl 3.9: Reign - Review
lassegalsgaard24 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
So, as I have expressed many times now, "Supergirl" is my least favorite of the four shows in the Arrowverse. One of the things that the show has always lacked is a great villain that really felt like a challenge to Kara. The first season started to set up a good villain with Astra, but she was killed off halfway through in favor of some evil male Kryptonian who I personally never got into. And then, the second season featured an ocean of different villains, before finally deciding to use Mon-El's evil mother. Again, a very lame and uninteresting villain. So far, this season has only really been able to offer some very lame episodes featuring Morgan Edge, who originally looked like the main villain to me. However, as the season has progressed, it has become very easy to see that Reign was always meant to be the main villain, and I am very happy that she has finally arrived, because she has done something that I didn't think was possible: creating an interesting, powerful villain.

To be fair, this would have been a really good episode, even without Reign. She doesn't show up until very late, but there were many other things to enjoy. The first thing is that Mon-El is actually not a useless character this time around. They are doing something great with him and finally introducing the Legion of Superheroes, thereby giving him a real purpose in the show. I liked the opening scene that really explaining the Legion's situation and what happened to them, as well as getting some clarification of what actually happened to Mon-El when he was send into space.

The writing in this episode was not as bad as previous episodes. There were some great moments between the majority of the cast, especially at the Christmas party where the characters had some time to just focus on being happy and not focus on being superheroes or secret agents. I like those moments in these show, and unfortunately, we don't get that many of them. I will say, though, that some of the writing in the episode was really cringeworthy, and felt more like a regular "Supergirl" writing effort. There is some really bad dialogue, especially in the very first scene between Samantha and Ruby, where Samantha said something that felt like it was written for a sketch comedy or something like that.

I like the role that religion is playing in this season. It doesn't feel ham-fisted, and it actually feels different and exciting. They have never really touched on that element before in these shows, so the fact that they are doing it here is actually a blow of fresh air. They are also doing a much better job of making it seem relevant than something like "Legends of Tomorrow" is.

And then, we can talk about Reign, because she was great in this episode. The big spotlight moment she got was her battle with Supergirl, in which she constantly had the upperhand and totally kicked her butt. This is something that I have missed in "Supergirl," because even though Supergirl has gotten her ass beaten in the past, it always felt very forced. It never felt like Supergirl was using all of her powers to try and fight off the villain. However, this time she was using everything she could to try and defeat Reign, and she did get a fair amount of blows in, but ultimately, she was the big loser of the fight, which I really appreciated. I hope that they continue this momentum with Reign, and doesn't end up her making her another mediocre big bad.

And Morgan Edge is still useless... The only purpose he serves in this show is some kind of threat to Lena, but they haven't used him to his full potential either. If the writers have nothing more to offer with this character, than just another second grade villain, then they should get rid of him quickly. He has been underused in this whole season, and it doesn't seem like they are going to do anything remotely intriguing with him.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Still getting beat up by villians
For a supergirl, she sure keeps getting beat up a lot.

By the way, did anyone see the fallacy in this episode? If supergirl and reign are both from Krypton, and supposedly have equal super powers from our yellow sun, then the best that should happen in a fight is a tie. But nope, supergirl gets beat up and bloody, which is another fallacy isn't it? If nothing can pierce her skin she shouldn't be getting cuts and bruises and bleed.
2 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A strange devil
timjtraver30 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I know it's not meant to be a true representation of the devil, but this Kryptonian devil is not very devil-like. She said herself she's a bringer of truth, justice, and judgement for sin. That's the exact opposite of the devil.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Lame episode.
nbastreetmaster11 December 2017
One of the not so great episodes in season 3 so far. The whole Samantha starting out on the show as a nice person then eventually turning into a villain for Supergirl has been recycled and re-used in past seasons of this show. Supergirl needs some new ideas in there episodes. Cause it becomes stale and boring to watch an idea get reused too much times.
1 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed