For starters, I'm a longtime fan of the 2004 movie. It was a significant part of my preteen/teen years. Easily one of my all-time favorite films. The Broadway musical, which I got to see last year, I also love. If a movie I love can be expanded on by songs and I don't hate it, that's an accomplishment.
I was brimming with hype as soon as I learned a movie musical was in the works. I saw it tonight... and I didn't love it. Now, it's not bad by means. I just felt deflated by the end of the first act. I knew the changes were coming, and I was ready. The new song "What Ifs" felt too much like a Disney musical opening song, in line with how underwhelmed I was with "Welcome to Rosas" in Wish.
"Where Do You Belong" could've been a perfect intro to the cafeteria scene. Jaquel Spivey and Auli'i Cravalho would definitely nail it. A lot of dialogue is nearly word for word of the original, and lack the bite they had 20 years ago. Reneé Rapp slays as Regina, easily the best performance. "Meet the Plastics" was so whittled down without Gretchen and Karen's verses. I also wasn't feeling any chemistry between Cady and Aaron. Angourie Rice seemed like she was just along for the ride (I loved her in The Nice Guys) and Christopher Briney is cute but he lacked the charm for me.
Bebe Wood and Avantika's portrayals of Gretchen and Karen, granted their characters are Regina's lackeys, have some of that vibe. "What's Wrong with Me" felt what it should be but "Sexy" came out of nowhere, like they're ticking boxes for giving everyone a spotlight. Maybe it's the whole overt social media presence. "Someone Gets Hurt" is where my attention began to come back, and "Revenge Party", which is my favorite song, is an absolute delight.
It seems that the most cut songs lies in the second half; as Damian's showstopping Act II opener "Stop" got the axe, Jaquel Spivey got Cady's verses on "Apex Predator". In the production I saw, the reprise of "What's Wrong with Me" swung right outta nowhere, and "Fearless" could've been this epic number after 'you can't sit with us!' With roughly 45 minutes remaining, the plot just forced ahead to Regina getting plowed by a bus and the Burn Book leak. "World Burn" is Regina peak, and it is glorious.
Around the time "I'd Rather Be Me" comes on, there's a few neat tidbits that stand out, like Ms. Norbury and Mr. Duvall being in a relationship, one of the trust fall apologies being a girl apologizing to her friend for accusing her of dragging during one of the songs (and Ms. Norbury casually waving it off), and when Cady is recruited into the Mathletes, a brief exchange about 'making "squills" happen' comes right out of the stage show. "Do This Thing", performed during the competition, was cut, with a "Stupid with Love" reprise in its place. The Spring Fling scene puts a smile on my face, but "I See Stars" also falls victim to being shortened, and sung by another character (making for a nice brick joke).
It's not perfect, nor is it bad. It's just fine. Honestly, I guess that's all I can really ask for. It could've been complete garbage. I'm glad it wasn't, and now my friends will be happy because I'm not harping on about it anymore. 7.5/10.
I was brimming with hype as soon as I learned a movie musical was in the works. I saw it tonight... and I didn't love it. Now, it's not bad by means. I just felt deflated by the end of the first act. I knew the changes were coming, and I was ready. The new song "What Ifs" felt too much like a Disney musical opening song, in line with how underwhelmed I was with "Welcome to Rosas" in Wish.
"Where Do You Belong" could've been a perfect intro to the cafeteria scene. Jaquel Spivey and Auli'i Cravalho would definitely nail it. A lot of dialogue is nearly word for word of the original, and lack the bite they had 20 years ago. Reneé Rapp slays as Regina, easily the best performance. "Meet the Plastics" was so whittled down without Gretchen and Karen's verses. I also wasn't feeling any chemistry between Cady and Aaron. Angourie Rice seemed like she was just along for the ride (I loved her in The Nice Guys) and Christopher Briney is cute but he lacked the charm for me.
Bebe Wood and Avantika's portrayals of Gretchen and Karen, granted their characters are Regina's lackeys, have some of that vibe. "What's Wrong with Me" felt what it should be but "Sexy" came out of nowhere, like they're ticking boxes for giving everyone a spotlight. Maybe it's the whole overt social media presence. "Someone Gets Hurt" is where my attention began to come back, and "Revenge Party", which is my favorite song, is an absolute delight.
It seems that the most cut songs lies in the second half; as Damian's showstopping Act II opener "Stop" got the axe, Jaquel Spivey got Cady's verses on "Apex Predator". In the production I saw, the reprise of "What's Wrong with Me" swung right outta nowhere, and "Fearless" could've been this epic number after 'you can't sit with us!' With roughly 45 minutes remaining, the plot just forced ahead to Regina getting plowed by a bus and the Burn Book leak. "World Burn" is Regina peak, and it is glorious.
Around the time "I'd Rather Be Me" comes on, there's a few neat tidbits that stand out, like Ms. Norbury and Mr. Duvall being in a relationship, one of the trust fall apologies being a girl apologizing to her friend for accusing her of dragging during one of the songs (and Ms. Norbury casually waving it off), and when Cady is recruited into the Mathletes, a brief exchange about 'making "squills" happen' comes right out of the stage show. "Do This Thing", performed during the competition, was cut, with a "Stupid with Love" reprise in its place. The Spring Fling scene puts a smile on my face, but "I See Stars" also falls victim to being shortened, and sung by another character (making for a nice brick joke).
It's not perfect, nor is it bad. It's just fine. Honestly, I guess that's all I can really ask for. It could've been complete garbage. I'm glad it wasn't, and now my friends will be happy because I'm not harping on about it anymore. 7.5/10.
Tell Your Friends