Paul Thomas Anderson's BOOGIE NIGHTS was an excellent story of ambition, success and failure, and the relationships that are born out of catharsis. Explicit and unflinching, it kept me hooked for the entire running time, every scene charged with emotion - joy, sadness, tragedy and wisdom all tied together it what was surely one of the best films of that year.
I had heard many good things about this film: the great performances, the deft use of music, the stirring emotional crescendoes. The film does not fail in these respects. The mouth-watering cast-list will draw any film fan, and the standard of acting is very high indeed. The score is exquisite too, but unfortunately the good points end here. MAGNOLIA is, in short, a beautiful waste of time.
(SOME MILD SPOILERS FOLLOW)
The script of MAGNOLIA is woefully inadequate for such a long and complex film. Anderson enjoys hearing the word 'c**t' uttered fiercely - and with tiresome frequency - from the mouths of A-list celebs; I don't share his penchants. Just as Shakespeare's sprawling Troilus and Cressida is clogged with pleasantries that makes the dialogue trawl through mud, Anderson's multi-layered epic struggles to breathe beneath a roughly-wrought mesh of expletives. Pubescent boys might find it hilarious, but I doubt that this is the desired effect. I found it, after a while, very grating indeed.
Anderson's film does not just contain one person dying of Cancer, but two. That's right, an extra 100% slow-death-by-cancer for your money; a sort of "buy one get one free." This struck me as an infuriating contrivance, but sadly it is the first of many. The film succeeds as a series of vignettes to music, but the threads are very loosely, if at all, tied together. My patience was exhausted after a couple of hours when I finally realized that it was all just a heap of spaghetti.
There are many beautiul moments in this film that are beaten down by a constant crassness that, unlike the witty trashmouth philosophy of a Tarantino or a Scorcese, degrades the film and actually works against the realism of the scenarios. Nobody swears that much. Not even Ozzy Osbourne's guitar player.
Anderson's film is, to me, a failed experiment. All credit to him for trying, though. MAGNOLIA is an ambitious film that aims high and misses the target, but that doesn't make it an entirely unrewarding experience. There are many sequences that are extremely powerful and the performances are remarkable. Sadly though, there are as many negatives as there are positives and to cap it all the ending absolutely stinks. Inadequate in the extreme, it had me gnashing my teeth and gouging out parts of my own face.
(SPOILERS END!)
To conclude, Anderson's film is ambitious, pointless, spasmodically exquisite - if I was being generous, I would call it a brilliant film that was born before it was properly formed; if I was not being generous, I would say it was a frivolous and depressing waste of time.
1 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends