Wanted to give a 10 based on season 1, but season 2 is just a straight re-enactment. I love the narration, which is why I watched the first season because of the podcast. I like background information, different stories related to the one I'm watching. But Aaron Mahnke has the best voice, season 3 (if they get one) needs to be like season 1. The podcast is why a lot of people watch this in the first place it's why I did.