I loved the first season but the second season was absolute pants. This was best illustrated by the scene on the beach in the final episode. How on earth did he manage to bury himself in the sand with the gun without someone else helping him? Absolutely logic defying nonsense.
3 Reviews
S2 China Girl: Great cast, but the plotting and character movements don't really work or engage
bob the moo12 November 2017
Towards the end of this second season, I checked my user comments of the first, because I was doubting what I had felt about the latter. The comments confirmed how I felt, and how many of my issues continued into this second season. In that way I suppose I have no right to complain – although in fairness, everything I liked about the first season is also here in the second.
Specifically those elements relate to the delivery. There is a great sense of tone and atmosphere to this season, just as there was in the first. The landscape may have changed, but the sense of pain, distance, and space is still there. So too are the performances, which are roundly strong whether in the recognizable faces or otherwise. The weakness of this season is not in how they deliver it but rather in what they are delivering. The plot rides a lot on coincidence – at first but also throughout. Characters all converge, which in and of itself is not necessarily a bad thing (after all, we follow these characters because they are part of the same story), but the issue is that from the first episode the characters are already clustered in a very small space; there are some outliers perhaps, but still everyone is half a step removed from one another. This smacks of convenience and kept me from going with the story, as it all felt too tidy to do it like this – putting everyone together.
The narrative also fails to really flow. It has ideas and action, but in its main thrust it doesn't sell itself as a drama. The performances within this messy affair are very strong as I said, and they sell it more than it deserves to be sold, but they can only do so much. If anything, at the end, it is hard not to feel like the cast deserved to have better – in particular Moss, Christie, Tang, and a scenery chewing Dencik. It is a quality season in some ways, but it is overly trite, convenient, and asks the cast to do a lot of heavy lifting without giving them a lot of help.
Specifically those elements relate to the delivery. There is a great sense of tone and atmosphere to this season, just as there was in the first. The landscape may have changed, but the sense of pain, distance, and space is still there. So too are the performances, which are roundly strong whether in the recognizable faces or otherwise. The weakness of this season is not in how they deliver it but rather in what they are delivering. The plot rides a lot on coincidence – at first but also throughout. Characters all converge, which in and of itself is not necessarily a bad thing (after all, we follow these characters because they are part of the same story), but the issue is that from the first episode the characters are already clustered in a very small space; there are some outliers perhaps, but still everyone is half a step removed from one another. This smacks of convenience and kept me from going with the story, as it all felt too tidy to do it like this – putting everyone together.
The narrative also fails to really flow. It has ideas and action, but in its main thrust it doesn't sell itself as a drama. The performances within this messy affair are very strong as I said, and they sell it more than it deserves to be sold, but they can only do so much. If anything, at the end, it is hard not to feel like the cast deserved to have better – in particular Moss, Christie, Tang, and a scenery chewing Dencik. It is a quality season in some ways, but it is overly trite, convenient, and asks the cast to do a lot of heavy lifting without giving them a lot of help.
Some of the worst television I have ever watched
FilmMovieTV134 November 2021
I don't know where to start. It's horrendous. Terrible. Awful.
I watched it because of the high reviews but please don't waste your time.
There is no real storyline, the acting is terrible, there is too much going on and it's all over the place. The men are horrendous and out of nowhere seem to make inappropriate passes to the main detective that are weird, awkward and out of place.
I cannot stand this programme. One of the worst things I've ever watched.
I watched it because of the high reviews but please don't waste your time.
There is no real storyline, the acting is terrible, there is too much going on and it's all over the place. The men are horrendous and out of nowhere seem to make inappropriate passes to the main detective that are weird, awkward and out of place.
I cannot stand this programme. One of the worst things I've ever watched.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
